ZEN lab
Numerical and
Experimental Zoology
The uniqueness of Erebia pandrose
We are strongly committed to the study of Apennine populations through an integrated approach that combines an assessment of diversity at the faunal and genetic level and data collection that involves the use of standardized methods and citizen science.
​
Erebia pandrose sevoensis is an endemic subspecies in the Apennines. It lives only on the highest peaks of the Laga Mountains and it is genetically unique. This population is likely to be at high risk of extinction as a result of climate change and it was feared that it had already disappeared in recent decades. The climate crisis, in fact, is particularly pressing for the high-Apennine populations who live in areas warmer than other mountain ranges such as the Alps and the Pyrenees.
Studying the adverse effects of climate change on animal and plant species is one of the key points for biodiversity conservation. The mountain butterflies and in particular the populations present on the Apennines, provide an excellent model. Among these the butterfly Erebia pandrose is rapidly becoming a symbol of the consequences of climate change and the fight against these.
High-altitude mountain butterflies are very vulnerable to global warming, which paradoxically risk freezing to death. Their larvae, in fact, exploit the thermal insulation provided by the snowy layers to hibernate at temperatures milder than those of the atmosphere. Rising temperatures cause the snow melting early, thus exposing the larvae to excessively cold temperatures for their survival during the winter. To survive, therefore, the mountain butterflies are forced to move towards higher and colder areas: but this strategy remains impossible for the species that already occupy the tops of the mountains.
The Apennines, which represent an important hotspot of mountain biodiversity in Italy, provide the opportunity to study how climate change impacts on insect populations, and in particular on high mountain butterflies. Many of these populations are extremely isolated from each other and have developed in the course of their evolutionary history a strong genetic differentiation, which has allowed the formation of numerous endemisms. Endemisms represent the most precious part of the biodiversity to be protected: with the term "endemism", in fact, we mean all those species, subspecies and genetic lines unique in the world, present exclusively in a given area.
​
The protection of the Apennine endemisms and the fight against climate change led our team to study as a model the high-altitude butterfly Erebia pandrose.
This species lives in habitats above the 2000 m and is present in the main European and Asian mountain ranges. In the Apennines, however, there is only one isolated population, which was last reported in 1977 on the top of the highest massif of the Laga Mountains, Mount Gorzano. Since then his stay in the Apennines had not been verified. The rediscovery and study of this population, 400 km far from the nearest alpine population, was the subject of the initiative Butterfly Week 2019. But the biggest discovery was that Erebia pandrose was not found in 2019 in the same area where it had been reported 42 years earlier, but 200 m higher. This shift of almost 5m/year is a clear sign of the effects of climate change and leaves strong fears about the future permanence of this species in the Apennines.
Subsequent analyses of mitochondrial DNA have made possible to discover the genetic uniqueness of this species, which identifies it as a precious Apennine endemism. To assess its chance of survival in the future, we applied a statistical model of species distribution. This analysis made possible to establish the current climate needs of E. pandrose and to predict its distribution in the next 20-40 years.
As feared, the endemic population of the Apennines has a very high probability of extinction, not finding more suitable habitats for their survival. This was already witnessed by his ascent to the mountain and would lead to the disappearance of a very precious element of Italian biodiversity. Erebia pandrose can be defined as a "flag species", drawing attention to the unique parts of biodiversity at risk of extinction: it reminds us of the need and urgency to act to counter the effects of climate change and for the
Here you can read our article in open access